Skip to main content

UPDATE: I just wanted to thank everyone who recommended this post, and shared it via social media. You have made this diary my "Avatar."

Yesterday, I posted a comment laying out several reasons why the GOP was basically walking into a trap on the Bowe Bergdahl story. It got such a positive response, that I decided to expand it into this diary. (You can follow me on twitter @hesiod2k11).

Since I posted the comment, there have been a few developments that even add MORE to my argument. So, without further ado....

As the actual FACTS start coming out about Bowe Bergdahl, here is what we know:

1. Bergdahl had left his base without permissions on at least one prior occasion, and had come back! This is according to a report in the Army Times. In fact, his fellow soldiers failed to report it at the time. The implications of this are huge. It means that it would be impossible to prove desertion under UCMJ Article 85, because you cannot prove he intended to leave permanently. Specifically, that article states:

(a) Any member of the armed forces who–

    (1) without authority goes or remains absent from his unit, organization, or place of duty with intent to remain away therefrom permanently;

    (2) quits his unit, organization, or place of duty with intent to avoid hazardous duty or to shirk important service; or

    (3) without being regularly separated from one of the armed forces enlists or accepts an appointment in the same or another on of the armed forces without fully disclosing the fact that he has not been regularly separated, or enters any foreign armed service except when authorized by the United States; is guilty of desertion.

The only two provisions that remotely could be applicable to Bowe Bergdahl are subsections (1) and (2). The first one is eliminated by the fact that he had done this before. Given that he returned on the prior occasion, it would be extremely difficult to prove an intent to "remain away....permanently." The second subsection is also difficult to prove if he left his base at night, when he was not otherwise on duty. So, as a consequence, you can pretty much rule out Bergdahl being charged with "desertion." At worst, he can be charged under Article 86: Absence Without Leave. That is a far less serious charge, and "time served" as a POW of the Haqqani network would probably be deemed sufficient punishment. Which, incidentally, would also considered an extenuating circumstance under that article.

UPDATE: The 35 page classified Army report (as reported to the New York Times) that was compiled 2 months after Bergdahl disappeared, concluded that he had left his unit twice, not once. And the Army blamed lax security practices and a lack of discipline. Moreover, the supposed letter he left confessing to everything was not mentioned in the report at all.

2. According to the now famous article by Michael Hastings about Bergdahl, his unit was basically a bunch of undisciplined fuck ups who went out on patrol without helmets, lost weapons, totally lacked morale and respect for military authority, etc. At least two commanders were actually demoted! So, you have to take with a grain of salt the accusations being made against Bergdahl by these people. Especially now that we know they failed to report Bergdahl left the base without permission on a prior occasion, and are still telling the media that he is a "deserter" when they know damn well that's not true.

3. The New York Times has also reported that it is almost impossible to attribute the losses the unit suffered to Bergdahl, or looking for Bergdahl. Given the lack of unit discipline, etc. One wonders whether Bergdahl is being scapegoated by these people, who were drummed up by GOP political operatives. You don't want to minimize the pain of the families of the lost soldiers. But, frankly, there is a tremendous amount of misinformation being pushed. And, a lot of speculation. It's just an unprovable allegation.

4. And, finally, Bergdahl's apparent heroism while in captivity has been almost completely ignored and glossed over. The Daily Beast originally reported that Bergdahl lulled his captors into believing he was sympathetic to them, and when they let their guard down he escaped for 3 days. When they finally found him in a hand-dug trench he covered with leaves, he was nearly naked an exhausted. Yet, it took 5 Taliban to subdue him as he fought back trying to avoid being recaptured.

Just last night, we found out that he escaped not once, but twice! Because of this, his captors kept moving him around and kept him under tight wraps. This made it exceedingly difficult and risky to attempt a rescue mission.

And, finally, the infamous "ashamed to be an American" e-mails that numbnuts like Sarah Palin keep using to attacking Bergdahl, were actually quite patriotic in context. He was complaining about the low caliber of person he had to suffer through in his unit, and how crappily they treated the Afghans (In one case, he said they indifferently ran over a child with a truck!). He was ashamed of the way the military operated there.

He was not expressing a desire to join the Taliban. He felt sympathy for the Afghan civilians who were being mistreated and abused by both sides. (These e-mails were reported in Michael Hastings' profile pieces).

When all is said and done, and Bergdahl is allowed to give his side of the story, the Republicans and Conservatives who were attacking him are going to regret it.

One other point on this that I didn't address in my comment. All of the crazy rightwingers who are suggesting that Bergdahl be executed for desertion are even more batshit crazy than it might seem at first. Even if he WAS guilty of desertion (a proposition which is extremely doubtful at this point), only one U.S. service member has been executed for the offense since the Civil War! That man was Pvt. Eddie Slovik during World War II. In his case, he signed a confession -- over the objections of his commanders! - and was defiant of military authority. Eventually, Dwight Eisenhower authorized his execution to set an example.

Moreover, in 1974 President Gerald Ford signed a conditional amnesty for Vietnam War deserters, if they agreed to two years of public service in some other capacity.

And, finally, the lone soldier convicted in connection with the My Lai massacre of Civillian Vietnamese villagers during Vietnam -- Lt. William Calley -- had his sentence reduced to House arrest and then finally commuted to time served by President Nixon after 3 years.

And, to make this even more pertinent, Staff Sgt. Robert Bales, who plead guilty to murdering 16 Afghan Civilians in their homes, was sentenced to life in prison without possibility of parole.

In other words, the batshit rightwingers want to impose a sentence on Bowe Bergdahl that is a) unsupported by any evidence; b) hasn't been imposed on a US Soldier in 70 years, and only once in 140 years; and c) more harsh than what was imposed on convicted mass murderers of civilians.

The lemming like nature of these profoundly disturbed wackos can be summarized in the following tweet:

7:44 AM PT: Just a note: This diary was meant to go viral to get these facts spread as far as possible. So, if you can, please tweet it, or post it to Facebook, etc. It is designed to be a one-stop informational tool for people who want to fight back against the disinformation on social media.

12:16 PM PT: Thanks to one of the commenters for linking to this well-researched post on Fark, which goes a long way toward debunking the claims that Bergdahl's capture led to all the deaths people are asserting.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, Jill, SME in Seattle, Pat K California, claude, Thumb, RakDaddy, Alumbrados, paradox, Angie in WA State, JWC, Mimikatz, Sylv, Mark Noel, DeminNewJ, RF, Mudshark, LeislerNYC, CJB, Val, ROGNM, Mogolori, scribeboy, oofer, Phoenix Woman, Radiowalla, decisivemoment, grollen, copymark, JeffSCinNY, mwm341, laurak, Timaeus, assyrian64, Trendar, Don Quixote, Geenius at Wrok, Cali Scribe, Pandora, TrueBlueMajority, lost, madmsf, Outsourcing Is Treason, PeterHug, DebtorsPrison, Emerson, karlpk, MouseThatRoared, TheGreatLeapForward, Shockwave, Fabienne, just another vet, Minnesota Deb, Wintermute, oblomov, ChicDemago, CleverNickName, kpardue, cotterperson, hyperstation, Jay C, richardak, Stein, mslat27, eeff, dsb, MakeChessNotWar, Pompatus, polecat, Do Something, freelunch, Woody, red moon dog, NCJim, windwardguy46, Walt starr, emelyn, MarkInSanFran, nightsweat, expatjourno, Creosote, davelf2, Bugsby, regis, JLFinch, Bruce The Moose, geordie, erinmblair, rasbobbo, Gustogirl, workersuntie, hestal, Zinman, missLotus, TravnTexas, 88kathy, Babsnc, susans, TracieLynn, EricS, sponson, cskendrick, Einsteinia, BlackSheep1, kalihikane, mbayrob, sja, Bring more on, estamm, whenwego, ellefarr, highacidity, KMc, Pithy Cherub, boadicea, gayntom, KS McCann, mrblifil, otto, xopher, Aquarius40, farmerhunt, chimpy, Frederick Clarkson, Dhavo, denig, Rujax206, wishingwell, sngmama, PeteZerria, librarianman, Terre, fumie, Glinda, mchristi314, Cedwyn, admiralh, hopeful, sidnora, Everbody, dksbook, aitchdee, Brit, wader, revsue, Quege, Lilyvt, Texknight, manneckdesign, kharma, psnyder, Joe Bacon, hangingchad, emmasnacker, NYC Sophia, Dallasdoc, duncanidaho, Damnit Janet, goobop, Bulldawg, wdrath, NYFM, niteskolar, Jujuree, DSC on the Plateau, Bluehawk, Sychotic1, defluxion10, Catte Nappe, Calidrissp, samoashark, rlharry, bsegel, lcrp, 2dot, Brian82, Chun Yang, bwintx, Matt Esler, JayBat, zerelda, Sembtex, side pocket, Hillbilly Dem, KayCeSF, Vicky, tomjones, NapaJulie, hayden, ScienceMom, Steven D, Black Max, Paul Hogarth, rickeagle, realalaskan, solesse413, boran2, Josiah Bartlett, rmx2630, Sybil Liberty, xxdr zombiexx, Sassy, sebastianguy99, Armand451, J Orygun, environmentalist, Frank Vyan Walton, My Philosophy, Gowrie Gal, sb, davidkc, harlinchi, sachristan, Dirk McQuigley, Skennet Boch, G2geek, bloomer 101, Bluesee, escapee, dark11star, Skaje, jrooth, Ckntfld, ichibon, jfdunphy, UncleCharlie, blueyedace2, caul, subtropolis, Tonedevil, Lying eyes, Chinton, Erik the Red, sc kitty, Militarytracy, sap, Alice Venturi, JohnB47, one of 8, Simplify, caliberal2001, kefauver, basquebob, terrypinder, dewtx, viral, stagemom, Brooke In Seattle, YucatanMan, Kevskos, Gary Norton, reflectionsv37, FutureNow, fixxit, eru, owlbear1, bleeding blue, dansk47, cfk, majcmb1, SaraBeth, Sun Tzu, jimstaro, where4art, aaraujo, Inland, Fury, cspivey, Overseas, quaoar, Little Lulu, most peculiar mama, blue jersey mom, ivorybill, jane123, RichterScale, sunbro, ord avg guy, Cecile, kaliope, PinHole, brentut5, SBandini, Tunk, spunhard, petestern, Blu Gal in DE, Shotput8, dbadw, Rusty in PA, sodalis, Joes Steven, Pluto, sillia, Lindy, peacestpete, Ekaterin, SocioSam, Box of Rain, kkjohnson, Alan Arizona, zozie, Oye Sancho, noweasels, xaxnar, begone, SoulCatcher, Mother Mags, MadGeorgiaDem, kishik, WuChier, third Party please, elliott, Knucklehead, sideboth, poco, atdnext, snazzzybird, BachFan, BalanceSeeker, tommymet, Debbie in ME, Stephan Kuttner, myboo, Kingsmeg, cybersaur, 417els, Mr Bojangles, Clytemnestra, edwardssl, BlueInARedState, tobendaro, emeraldmaiden, Themistoclea, HoundDog, Gorette, Yellow Canary, raptavio, seefleur, Dvalkure, Patriot4peace, The Wizard, Naniboujou, Wary, slampros, SherriG, DarkestHour, MJ via Chicago, shrike, global citizen, StrayCat, Lashe, philipmerrill, gpoutney, Rosaura, NCJan, Crashing Vor, DiesIrae, SadieSue, katrinka, JVolvo, unclebucky, plf515, MarciaJ720, Jjc2006, boatsie, tommyfocus2003, ER Doc, Up to here, doinaheckuvanutjob, middleagedhousewife, MBNYC, justiceputnam, anninla, llbear, onionjim, SingerInTheChoir, IL clb, rage, Unknown Quantity, CA Nana, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, BB10, cherryXXX69, blueoregon, kurt, equern, kurious, Bernie68, Temmoku, AllanTBG, sea note, markthshark, Little, Pandoras Box, PatConnors, Aaa T Tudeattack, cpresley, Tempus Figits, krwheaton, old wobbly, Sapere aude, bear83, FoundingFatherDAR, john07801, dpinzow, Karen from Maui, Cronesense, nipit, Habitat Vic, hawaii2, Cat Whisperer, Loudoun County Dem, camlbacker, weneedahero, Debs2, devis1, ColoTim, gloriana, EdSF, Stwriley, puakev, yoduuuh do or do not, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, LillithMc, Blue State 68, wildweasels, jeanette0605, noofsh, Matt Z, flumptytail, Dave in Northridge, shesaid, certainot, deepeco, Ninepatch, Shadowmage36, newpioneer, bnasley, mbh1023, NoMoJoe, HCKAD, jayden, jedennis, buckshot face, martyinsfo, tcdup, Oreo, BaritoneWoman, bobswern, jnhobbs, millwood, Bridge Master, carpunder, OIL GUY, RudiB, pioneer111, Wreck Smurfy, cececville, christianlsv, leonard145b, skod, JML9999, tj iowa, Steve CXS, janatallow, eyesoars, cloudbustingkid, zorp, Azubia, sable, dizzydean, aseth, keyscritter, thewhitelist, roycej, TomP, Empower Ink, cville townie, gizmo59, Zacapoet, fb, Mighty Ike, Mike Williams, JDWolverton, river0, MKinTN, MissyH, gundyj, Amor Y Risa, revm3up, jack 1966, TX Freethinker, BobBlueMass, JaxDem, gfv6800, walja, Captain C, signals, Phil N DeBlanc, GAS, wayoutinthestix, spacejam, WilliamE, scooter in brooklyn, ScottyUrb, Robert Naiman, 6412093, OleHippieChick, Sixty Something, Youffraita, Senor Unoball, lamzdotes, Involuntary Exile, dadadata, NewDealer, Ronald England, smrichmond, elwior, skohayes, filby, CDH in Brooklyn, Buckeye Nut Schell, monkeybrainpolitics, sandav, willipr, Lujane, rssrai, tofumagoo, royce, pamelabrown, boatjones, Cassandra Waites, hwmnbn, MrJayTee, pickandshovel, triplepoint, Conium, Missys Brother, Jeff Y, codairem, Gemina13, petulans, elpacifico66, TexanJane, Parthenia, gas28man, BYw, Keninoakland, Karl Rover, Al Fondy, suesue, HarpboyAK, JamieG from Md, Mayfly, billybam, dmhlt 66, watercarrier4diogenes, GrannyOPhilly, Diogenes2008, vmdairy, lissablack, GustavMahler, JBL55, Marnie1, LaFeminista, BvueDem, maggiejean, cadfile, prettygirlxoxoxo, Bule Betawi, multilee, artmartin, Ran3dy, MufsMom, J M F, zmom, Zorge, ceebee7, snackdoodle, don mikulecky, bobatkinson, ronnied, dharmasyd, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, LeftOfYou, Don Enrique, Methinks They Lie, janmtairy, WakeUpNeo, sburles, BlueInRedCincy, shopkeeper, mkor7, newyorknewyork, aunt blabby, petral, followyourbliss, geebeebee, elziax, glitterlust, bfitzinAR, papahaha, lastman, Leslie in KY, degreesofgray, hyper, Denise Oliver Velez, kevinpdx, Keith Pickering, Ibis Exilis, KenInCO, Thutmose V, Northern Light, stevenwag, sfarkash, jfromga, nancat357, MizKit, astral66, Livvy5, dsmyre, joe from Lowell, nocynicism, LookingUp, collardgreens, America Jones, Black Mare, Words In Action, cassandraX, BlueOak, Railfan, tambora, Just Bob, hotdamn, CTMTN, richdoll, Its the Supreme Court Stupid, commonmass, parse this, YellerDog, moenrj, FogCityJohn, willynel, LaughingPlanet, The Jester, NJpeach, serendipityisabitch, brunoboy, gramofsam1, politik, leftywright, piers, kjoftherock, SeattleTammy, secret38b, michelewln, Anima, klompendanser, Grainpaw, Crabby Abbey, LOrion, mookins, VickiL, freeport beach PA, Things Come Undone, appledown, ATFILLINOIS, Garfnobl, Eddie L, JoanMar, Stichey, samanthab, pixxer, kacemo, Hoopgreen, Kristina40, anonevent, Egalitare, DerAmi, DiegoUK, cai, Yasuragi, Jaimas, addisnana, Johnny Q, rja, Texnance, Betty Pinson, Patate, BlueFranco, ericlewis0, Otteray Scribe, Loose Fur, cocinero, petesmom, wwjjd, fiercefilms, soaglow, stevenaxelrod, JanG, mallyroyal, dot farmer, JClarkPDX, Quantumlogic, Mister Met, theKgirls, Onomastic, Maximilien Robespierre, PaDemTerry, yellow cosmic seed, kerflooey, Front Toward Enemy, agrenadier, Sal Bovoso, Lost Left Coaster, ozsea1, Captain Pants, StateofEuphoria, Will in Chicago, bgblcklab1, Tommye, DLWinMI, humanmancalvin, lady blair, sabo33, implicate order, KCthinking, Mr MadAsHell, Massapequa Dem, donaurora, swale44, poorbuster, Possiamo, OldGrammy, Susipsych, LSF, FarWestGirl, Situational Lefty, lexalou, mikejay611, OhioNatureMom, deeproots, lupinella, Outraged Mom, YallaDog, molunkusmol, boomerchick, mrsgoo, Haf2Read, marleycat, PorridgeGun, zukesgirl64, Lorikeet, AgavePup, sethtriggs, Carolyn in Oregon, Jasonhouse, IllanoyGal, thomask, Santa Susanna Kid, sonorelli, dle2GA, Attack Gardener, BarackStarObama, Tommy Aces, LeftCoastTom, gof, chickeeee, sofa turf, unapologeticliberal, MRA NY, createpeace, Reinvented Daddy, loblolly, worldlotus, RMForbes, enhydra lutris, chira2, myrmecia gulosa, bluedust, MinistryOfTruth, Imhotepsings, Caddis Fly, Andrew F Cockburn, old mark, Joe Jackson, Marihilda, bakeneko, Vatexia, Oilwellian, Eric Stetson, ratcityreprobate, SteelerGrrl, Catlady62, blackjackal, Sunspots, stlsophos, MikeBoyScout, leftykook, joanbrooker, Alfreda89, jham710, jadt65, Chitown Kev, CoyoteMarti, Rashaverak, caryltoo, nyer11Oak, Auriandra, Laurel in CA, Mathazar, mikeVA, Take a Hard Left, left over flower child, BlueDragon, YaNevaNo, SuWho, AnnetteK, Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom, Maggie33, livingthedream, quill, hulibow, Pinto Pony, nominalize, joelgp, daysey, i saw an old tree today, ridemybike, clubbing guy, Prairie D, Cordyc, tweeternik, Liberal Granny, MNGlasnant, KiB, RhodaA, bluezen, mkoz, OldDragon, Heart n Mind, anodnhajo, HPrefugee, cwsmoke, TheLizardKing, Chrislove, Siri, charliehall2, IndieGuy, ahumbleopinion, Eric Nelson, joanil, tb92, midgebaker, Joieau, pimutant, a2nite, Deep Texan, rukidingme, 2thanks, FloridaSNMOM, Trotskyrepublican, congenitalefty, dog in va, joeschmeaux, stellaluna, This old man, Mike RinRI, Forward is D not R, Halandri, jan4insight, carolanne, Karelin, reginahny, jts327, hardart, Lilredhead, MartyM, aznavy, howarddream, parakeet, lartwielder, ndaWilderness, sexgenderbody, wxorknot, jennyp, sweatyb, etherealfire, rat racer, Victim of Circumstance, monkeybox, FrY10cK, AverageJoe42, ItsaMathJoke, CitizenScientist, raina, Windtalker, wasatch, Robynhood too, Buckeye Liberal, CalBearMom, Arilca Mockingbird, live1, patb3550, Hammerhand, nthelurch, Raven Song, Stills, BobTheHappyDinosaur, allensl, Captain Chaos, Upie, mzkryz, Greenfinches, nuclear winter solstice, Lily O Lady, Jim Sylvester, jusjtim35, txdoubledd, onceasgt, koosah, simple serf, TheMeansAreTheEnd, countwebb, Flecked Carbon, Linda1961, remembrance, JayRaye, VeloDramatic, Thornrose, poopdogcomedy, shockratees, Witgren, P Carey, goodpractice, weck, Joy of Fishes, aresea, Alhambra, Drocedus, leeleedee, fargo2413, ggfkate, optimistic pizza, howabout, KatieAnnieOakley, northerntier, bwtsang, Icicle68, tuesdayschilde, BadKitties, Hey338Too, Jeanniebeannie, Timari, backwoodsbob, Patango, MountainPenelope, LilithGardener, Jim Domenico, Doodlebug9, Portia Elm, ChristineM, maregug, martianexpatriate, OregonWetDog, Rumor, Modified Dog, Gardener in PA, danjb, Mystic Michael, bobwilk, fredsfish, Volt3930, Kimba, Rich Lyles, Sally Foster, stuhunter2, richardvjohnson, VinnieSaltine, karma5230, hamjudo, panzergeek, eagleray, Kaylin, ExpatGirl, Nicodemus, redwolf68, pierre9045, luerwulf, jbsoul, Fish Man, KansasLib, Penny GC, gnosticator, icesailor, alx9090, Tex Arcana

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site